In this article
Hindu traditions hold a rich world of worship, philosophy, sacred stories and family practice. A lamp offered before a beloved deity, an Upanishadic discussion and a pilgrimage can all belong within that world. Understanding the word Hindutva requires a different kind of question: how has Hindu identity been expressed as a modern idea of nationhood?
Hinduism and Hindutva overlap in their references to Hindu culture, but they name different subjects. Keeping their meanings clear helps us discuss religion and political history with care for the people involved.
What Hinduism names
Hinduism is a broad name for related religious and cultural traditions with diverse scriptures, teachers and practices. Shaiva, Vaishnava and Shakta communities, for example, cherish different forms of the divine. Philosophers also disagree about the relationship between the self, the world and ultimate reality.
This diversity is more precise than saying every Hindu teaching says the same thing. In the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad’s dialogue with Maitreyi, questions about wealth lead to inquiry into the Self. In the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna teaches Arjuna through discussions of action, knowledge and devotion. Neither text functions as a modern political party programme.
What Savarkar meant by Hindutva
V. D. Savarkar’s Essentials of Hindutva, published in 1923, is a foundational text for modern Hindu nationalism. In its opening discussion, he explicitly distinguishes Hindutva from Hinduism and develops an account of collective identity extending beyond religious doctrine.
His definition draws on ancestry, shared culture and territory. In the section “Who is a Hindu?”, he describes India as both pitribhu, fatherland, and punyabhu, holy land. This is Savarkar’s proposed boundary of national-cultural belonging. It is not a definition accepted by every Hindu or by every community he groups within it.
The distinction matters especially where his text discusses Muslims and Christians: he excludes them from his definition when their holy lands lie outside India. That is an account of his argument, not a statement about those communities’ actual loyalty, cultural belonging or civic standing.
A comparison with room for complexity
Hinduism concerns religious life in its many forms: worship, ritual, ethics, knowledge and liberation. Hindutva, in Savarkar’s formulation, concerns the organization and boundaries of a national community. Hindu scriptures and lineages are sources for the former; modern ideological writings are essential sources for studying the latter.
The categories are therefore distinct without being historically sealed off from one another. Religious symbols can carry political meanings, and political thinkers can interpret religious heritage. Understanding one specific use requires identifying who is speaking, when, and in what setting.
Reading the debate responsibly
In a 2024 study, historian Eijiro Hazama traces changes in Savarkar’s thought leading to the 1923 text. The article’s English abstract presents his ideology as something developed through historical circumstances, rather than a timeless summary of Hindu religion. Only that accessible abstract is used here; the Japanese full article is not represented as read.
Religious diversity should also not be confused with proof that Hindu societies have always practiced equal inclusion. Traditions contain debate, change and conflicting social histories. Likewise, a person’s Hindu identity does not establish their political commitments. Careful discussion asks about a particular text, organization, policy or historical claim while allowing individuals to describe their own beliefs.
Sources and further reading
- Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 2.4, translated by F. Max Müller — 2.4.1–5 and 12–14; historical translation, paraphrased.
- Bhagavad Gita 3.30, translation by Swami Mukundananda — Sanskrit, word meanings and verse translation; commentary distinguished from the verse.
- V. D. Savarkar, Essentials of Hindutva — PDF pp. 3–4 and 39–44: distinction from Hinduism, ancestry/culture, fatherland and holy land.
- Eijiro Hazama, The Genealogy of V. D. Savarkar’s Hindutva Ideology, Journal of Religious Studies 98.2 (2024) — English abstract read in full; Japanese article not read.

