In this article
Hindutva is usually translated as “Hinduness.” In political history, it refers to a modern project of defining national identity around a Hindu people and civilisation. Understanding that usage helps readers distinguish a political argument from the varied devotional, philosophical and ritual lives of Hindus.
This article focuses on V.D.Savarkar’s influential formulation and its historical interpretation. It does not treat every Hindu as a supporter or opponent of one political position, and it does not use religious identity as evidence of a person’s loyalty.
A major formulation in 1923
Savarkar’s Essentials of Hindutva was published in 1923. Historian Vikram Visana places the development of Savarkar’s Hindu nationalism within the colonial prison experience and the changing political arguments of his lifetime. The tract’s national vision should therefore be read as a historical intervention, rather than as an ancient scripture.
In the section headed “Hindutva is different from Hinduism,” Savarkar explicitly distinguishes the two terms. He understands Hindutva as encompassing collective history and culture beyond a religious creed. That distinction belongs to his argument; it does not make religion irrelevant to his definition of belonging.
Reading a primary text means encountering what its author argued. It does not require adopting the author’s categories, descriptions of other communities or account of ancient history as established fact.
Land, ancestry and culture
Savarkar links national identity to a common land, inherited peoplehood and culture. He discusses language, historical memory, literature, rites and festivals as elements of that culture. These are ingredients in a proposed political unity, not a neutral inventory of everything every Hindu practises.
His language of common blood and race belongs to the tract’s historical vocabulary. It should not be treated as modern genetic classification or as proof of biological uniformity. Studying that language involves asking how it constructs a people and where it draws boundaries.
The tract also combines fatherland, pitribhu, with holy land, punyabhu. Shared attachment to territory alone is insufficient in its definition. Sacred geography helps determine whom Savarkar includes within the Hindu collective.
The central boundary
In “Who is a Hindu?”, Savarkar extends his collective category across several traditions originating in India. These classifications are his own; they should not override the self-understanding of Buddhist, Jain or Sikh communities.
The same section treats Muslims and Christians differently because their major sacred geographies lie outside India. This is an ideological boundary in the text. Its claims about divided allegiance describe Savarkar’s argument, not an established truth about those communities.
That tension helps explain why the idea is debated. An appeal to solidarity across internal divisions can also define conditions that exclude neighbours. Historical analysis needs to examine both features rather than presenting the tract only as cultural pride or only as a slogan.
How historians approach it
Visana interprets glory and humiliation as important organising concepts in Savarkar’s political thought. His study examines how stories, poetry and historical narratives were used to build collective identity. This is a named scholarly interpretation, not the final word on every aspect of Hindutva.
The wider history includes later adaptations by different organisations and thinkers. Claims about present parties, elections or law require separate, dated evidence; a 1923 text cannot by itself establish contemporary policy or everyone’s motives.
Reading with clarity
Useful questions are specific: which author, which text, which definition and which period? Keep national belonging, citizenship and personal religious practice distinct when evaluating an argument. This makes room for careful discussion of Hindu heritage while avoiding assumptions that all Hindus share a political ideology or that an ideological definition determines any neighbour’s worth.

